Why this rating: Bancor 3/Vortex largely wound down on mainnet; Carbon DeFi is the growth engine. BNT holders govern via on-chain BancorGovernance contract + Snapshot (563 proposals); protocol fees currently go to deficit repair, not BNT holders — procedural governance, no economic rights. GSA-3 fail: Carbon trading fees currently earmarked for BNT/ETH deficit repair per DAO policy, not BNT holders; Vortex buyback mechanism defunct on mainnet (still on some EVM chains per May 2026 proposal); On-chain BancorGovernance contract (BNT stake→vote) + Snapshot (bancornetwork.eth, 563 proposals); recent Snapshot activity Jun 2026 (taker-fee proposals); on-chain execution of Carbon settings not independently re-verified
GSA-3 fail: Carbon trading fees currently earmarked for BNT/ETH deficit repair per DAO policy, not BNT holders; Vortex buyback mechanism defunct on mainnet (still on some EVM chains per May 2026 proposal)
On-chain BancorGovernance contract (BNT stake→vote) + Snapshot (bancornetwork.eth, 563 proposals); recent Snapshot activity Jun 2026 (taker-fee proposals); on-chain execution of Carbon settings not independently re-verified
Carbon DeFi (arb-based) is the primary product; 2026 initiative cut stablecoin taker fees to 0.001%
No proposal history is available for Bancor in the current scanner window.
Metrics
Curated metric — next quarterly update. On-chain revenue, treasury, and distribution-enforcement reads are not yet wired for this DAO's space in the Institute's state files; the quarterly re-assessment cycle will populate this block.
GSA-3 fail: Carbon trading fees currently earmarked for BNT/ETH deficit repair per DAO policy, not BNT holders; Vortex buyback mechanism defunct on mainnet (still on some EVM chains per May 2026 proposal)
On-chain BancorGovernance contract (BNT stake→vote) + Snapshot (bancornetwork.eth, 563 proposals); recent Snapshot activity Jun 2026 (taker-fee proposals); on-chain execution of Carbon settings not independently re-verified
Carbon DeFi (arb-based) is the primary product; 2026 initiative cut stablecoin taker fees to 0.001%